Best Eyeliners in 2021

Eyeliners

Any lady would agree to the fact that having the best eyeliner in their vanity box is like having a diamond in possession. It is true due to the fact that a good eyeliner defines the depth, sharpness and shape of the eye. Eyes are the first to be noticed on any face and the first impression is made with eye contact. That pretty much sums up why we need to glam up those eyes. After all, poems have been written about how her winged eyes look iridescent in under those eyelashes. While eyelashes are natural and unique to everyone, why not level up the winged eyes a little more? Keeping in mind the different type of eyeliners, we have compiled a list of eyeliners from all the good eyeliner brands ranging from the best-rated eyeliner to the best eyeliner for winged eyes.

For those who are willing to experiment it out, there are few options such as the silver eyeliner to be used to bring out a dazzle from those eyes, the peach eyeliner to make a softer definition and the best purple eyeliner to make those eyes stand out with a pop. That’s pretty much the effort and the final choice is of course up to you. Let’s see which one of the below gets to be a part of your makeup kit soon:

Yves Saint Laurent Eyeliner Effet Faux Cils Shocking
  • Many colours
  • Gentle on skin
  • Easy to apply

SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner
  • Waterproof line
  • Lush/clean line
  • Skin-safe liner

View The Best Eyeliners Below

1. Inglot Matte Eyeliner Gel 75

Inglot Matte Eyeliner Gel 75

Inglot holds the record for producing an eyeliner in a rich shade of eggplant and also the best eyeliner that doesn’t smudge. Long lasting, even underwater, this is the best purple eyeliner out there. The gel is paraben free and has not been tested on animals. Now isn’t it too good to know that literally no animal testing has been done using Inglot products? The gel is multipurpose can be used as a body painting gel as well as an eye shadow. The gel has a silky consistency and leaves a sleek trail of purple on the eyes to give it an extra refined look. It is highly recommended that a separate brush of brush number 30T is used to give that extra finishing.

The application brush is not included with the package but also it is to be known that only the real branded products are delivered as Inglot doesn’t believe in compromising with quality. Some eyeliner reviews have also added that this product can be used even on the waterline safely. The product is also said to be looking brand new even after months of usage, which attests to its long shelf life.

See more information on Inglot Matte Eyeliner Gel 75.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • A rich shade of purple.
  • Long lasting.
  • Waterproof.
  • Silky gel consistency.
  • Can be used as both a body painting gel and an eye shadow.

Our Verdict

Next time you are planning on painting the town purple with elegantly defined winged eyes or the cat eyes with a purple element, Inglot has got it covered. With its added qualities like smudge resistance and waterproofness, the long-lasting eggplant eye definers are here to stay.

2. SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner #1 Matte Black

SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner #1 Matte Black

The best of the best Sephora eyeliners is a retraceable and waterproof eyeliner in a strong matte shade of black. One of the best eyeliner pencils out there, the Sephora matte eyeliner boasts of an easily gliding creamy texture, which means it when it is drawn over the eyes, the matte finish looks delicate while at the same time showing off the well-defined look. Though it is smudge resistant, with a bit of skill, you can make the ends of your eyes look smudged and get that semi-smoky look. The eyeliner has a built-in sharpener which can come handy when the tip needs to be a bit sharper. A smudge tip is also there to give that extra smudge you need.

It is the best waterproof eyeliner pencil for waterline which comes from a top rated brand. Also being one of the best drugstore eyeliner for tightlining, Sephora boasts highly of its eyeliner pencil. This amazingly crazy eyeliner has a sponge which comes along specially included in order to get those thick lines right. It stays on for long period of times and doesn’t even come off even when under the heaviest rain.

See more information on SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • Comes along with a built-in sharpener and a smudge tip.
  • Best for both waterline and tightlining.
  • Smudge resistant after application.
  • Matte finish.

Our Verdict

Sephora is a very top rated brand and their eyeliner is one of the fine examples of high quality and value for the price, although it is quite expensive. There is absolutely no reason why this one should not be considered as the best option for anyone who is looking for a product of good brand and quality.

3. Clio Waterproof Pen Liner, Kill Black/001, 0.018 Ounce

Clio Waterproof Pen Liner, Kill Black/001, 0.018 Ounce

Ever wondered how Korean women have their eyes look so defined, with all those perfect wings and sharp corners? The fact that Korean eyeliners are the best when it comes to the range of top dramatic eyeliners is true as they are one of the best drugstore pencil eyeliner that won’t smudge much. The best rated amongst them is the waterproof range of black liners from CLIO. The brand has won the award for best eyeliner for five years in a row. The unique felt pens with a spongy tip allow precise application without any smudges. The darkest and rich shade of black is due to the formulation with carbon black.

The cap of the pencil is airtight, which doesn’t allow the liquid to dry up. The product has a very impressive shelf life and it promises months of continuous usage. This is, by the way, the best liquid eyeliner which is quite a hit with the newbies and makeup pros alike. It is quite easy to use and can be wiped off easily with makeup remover. The application of this eyeliner doesn’t cause flakiness of the liquid and it leaves a sharp impression of magnificent winged eyes.

See more information on Clio Waterproof Pen Liner.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • Convenient application.
  • Long shelf life.
  • High definition.
  • Top rated brand for having won awards for the best eyeliner for 5 consecutive years.

Our Verdict

After all, that “best eyeliner of the year” awards that were recurrent for five years and the fact that it is actually a good one, do we need any other better reason? Our verdict is: Go for it, you won’t be disappointed.

4. LORAC Front of the Line PRO Liquid Eyeliner

LORAC Front of the Line PRO Liquid Eyeliner

If we have a pro eyeliner which can handle all our needs for eye makeup, we have a winner in Lorac Front of the Line PRO range of eyeliners. This luxury range of eyeliners are waterproof and smudge resistant and have a very long shelf life. The tip of the eyeliner is flexible making it easier to apply both thick and thin lines. These eyeliners are too good and it boasts of a unique automatic delivery system and it helps with precise application. The formulation doesn’t have harmful parabens, sulfates, synthetic fragrances, petrochemicals, phthalates or any of the synthetic dyes. To bring out the depth of your eyes, it is recommended you use the eyeliners along upper and lower lashes.

Since the chemicals used in its formulation are very less, the chances of allergic reactions are very less. The applicator is a soft brush that feels like cotton against the skin which makes it very skin friendly. The matte finish which is achieved in the end is flawless and close to perfection. With the option of a flexible brush, one is able to experiment with different types of lines, adding in few customised designs for the winged ends of the eyes.

See more information on LORAC Front of the Line PRO Liquid Eyeliner.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • Flexible brush tips.
  • No harmful chemicals added.
  • Waterproof.
  • Smudge resistant.

Our Verdict

These range of eyeliners are recommended highly for anyone who wants to experiment with their waterline and lashes. Since they have so much lesser chemicals included in their formulation, they are less likely to cause allergic reactions.

5. Kat Von D Tattoo Liner Trooper 0.55 ml/0.019 oz

Kat Von D Tattoo Liner Trooper 0.55 ml/0.019 oz

There’s one tattoo eyeliner we cannot simply miss out for its advanced felt tip doesn’t fray during the application. After all, it’s a one eyeliner stop for trying out different types of styles on those eyes. Waterline, tightlining, double wings, loops, curves and what not. When you got the darkest eyeliner in your vanity box, why worry about them? Kat Von D tattoo liner reviews are so generous which makes them one of the most popular and top rated brands. The brush tip is flexible and superfine and one feels as if a light feather is gliding over the skin and leaving the classic feathery touch.

One of the best waterproof eyeliner for the waterline, Kat Von D is also known for its high pigment which also makes it one of the darkest eyeliners on the list. It has strong resistance against smudges, run, fade, melt and cracking, in addition to last long, throughout the day. Also, the consistency of the liquid is great and it does not dry up that easily. A lot of hype has been generated around this amazing product simply because of its worth and value.

See more information on Kat Von D Tattoo Liner Trooper.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • Great consistency.
  • Can try out a variety of styles.
  • Fade resistant, crack resistant and waterproof.
  • One of the best darkest eyeliners.

Our Verdict

With so many good resistances and the darkest pigment adding in the benefits, this tattoo eyeliner is simply too irresistible.

6. Smashbox Always On Liquid Eye Liner – Black (24 Hour Wear, Ultra Fine Tip)

Smashbox Always On Liquid Eye Liner - Black (24 Hour Wear, Ultra Fine Tip)

When it comes to the perfect ergonomic eyeliners category, the winner is none other than Smashbox. The name sounds quite powerful yet humble, just like the ultra fine tip of that eyeliner drawing a perfectly coated line of black liquid to bring out the shape of the eyes in the most beautiful way. The high pigment formulation is waterproof and claims a no fade up to 24 hours. That is one day without having to reapply or worry about smudges and tricks with water. By combining with the Super Fan Mascara, it combines the looks and brings out a dazzling eyes effect.

Or rather getting others dazzled with the fuller looking eyes with the knockout rate dangerously high. One coat is enough for the modest users for daytime whereas one can play with wings to create a more dramatic effect at parties. Upon continuous usage, the product lasts for around 6 months before it can be fully used and discarded. One of the reviews even mentioned that it survived even through tears and was looking sharp as before. But it can be removed gently using a cleansing wipe or a makeup remover.

See more information on Smashbox Always On Liquid Eye Liner.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • It is really waterproof.
  • Just one coat is enough for the magic.
  • Ultra-fine tip.

Our Verdict

This eyeliner promises long shelf life, no fade up to 24 hours and best results and reviews. Nothing can stop it from being one of the best in the list.

7. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

One of the best selling products, Stila stay all day waterproof liquid eyeliner has proved itself to be one of the best over the counter eyeliner of all times. Available in twelve shades of awesomeness, these liquid eyeliners are great on both the darker and fairer skin tones. For anyone who wants to try out new funky styles along with the usual classic ones, stila is the brand to choose. The applicator brush just glides with ease, without any smudging, skipping or pulling. The layer of applied liquid dies quickly and it stays for a very long time. The liquid liner is waterproof and can be easily used by advanced makeup artists and beginners alike. The easy to apply formula is what makes it so unique. It is best to store the eyeliner in a vertical manner so as to keep the felt tip damp and smooth always, ready to use. Stila has been a brand name in whom many have trusted for the past 20 years. The legacy still lives on through all the products they have sold out till now.

See more information on Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • Brand quality.
  • Available in 20 different shades.
  • Ease of application.

Our Verdict

The brand name is so trustworthy and the eyeliner is too good for the record. One can try out as many shades to experiment.

8. Yves Saint Laurent Eyeliner Effet Faux Cils Shocking (Bold Felt Tip Eyeliner Pen)

Yves Saint Laurent Eyeliner Effet Faux Cils Shocking (Bold Felt Tip Eyeliner Pen) - # 1 Black 1.1ml/0.04oz

Yves Saint Laurent is quite a remarkable brand whose line of products have never failed to keep the fans following. The eyeliners from the Effect Faux Cils Shocking range has a large number of followers for its great characteristics. Though it is the most expensive eyeliner on this list, it is worth its the price. The felt tip applicator contains a carbon black pigment for the darkest shade of colour to be drawn over the eyes. The tip is smooth as a calligraphy feather’s tip and the liquid has a water-based formulation. Providing all the smooth curves, the eyeliner is free of petrochemicals, phthalates, sulfates, synthetic fragrances, triclosan and GMOs. The eyeliner guarantees 12 hours of fade resistant coating and it is removable by the usage of makeup remover or cleansing wipes.

See more information on Yves Saint Laurent Eyeliner Effet Faux Cils Shocking.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • Top quality brand.
  • Soft applicator tip.
  • Extra carbon pigment for extra darkness.
  • Free of petrochemicals, phthalates, sulfates, synthetic fragrances, triclosan and GMOs.

Our Verdict

The brand name is the best testimony we have; its perfect and quite advanced. Also, it belongs to the luxury line of eyeliners.

9. Too Faced Perfect Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner, Perfect Black, 0.04 Ounce

Too Faced Perfect Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner, Perfect Black, 0.04 Ounce

With a creamy consistency, the Too Faced Perfect Eyes Waterproof Eyeliners glide as easily as their liquid counterparts and have a lockdown of 8 hours without any smudges, cracks, flakes or anything which can ruin those beautifully drawn eyes. There are a total of six shades to choose from and to try out for different combinations for experimenting. Starting with the classic range, the shades are of good texture and also includes the cutting edge-couture. Each of the eyeliners includes a flexible- firm and bevelled smudger that helps in creating a smokey effect or fine and precisely drawn lines. The product is free of mineral oils, paraffin or parabens.

See more information on Too Faced Perfect Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • Flexi firm and bevelled smudger in place.
  • Available in six shades.
  • 8 hours of lockdown.

Our Verdict

It is quite a good eyeliner to try as it is helpful in creating both the smokey effect or precisely drawn lines.

10. L’Oreal Paris Pencil Perfect Self-Advancing Eyeliner

L'Oreal Paris Pencil Perfect Self-Advancing Eyeliner, Expresso, 0.01 Ounces

Smooth and soft, with a crème formulation, Loreal Paris pencil Self-Advancing eyeliners are the popular picks amongst the majority of the eyeliner users crowd. Efficient, and at the same time quite economical, these smudge proof eyeliners are a lifesaver to those who are looking for a product with value for money at a lower budget. It is overall in terms of its performance and reviews. For anyone with sensitive skin and eyes, these eyeliners are highly recommended for them. With a steady hand, anyone can draw dramatic upper and lower lashes and expect them to stay that way for a very long period of time. The tip can be made sharper and advanced in order to get the right tip

See more information on L’Oreal Paris Pencil Perfect Self-Advancing Eyeliner.

Compelling Reasons to Buy

  • Value for money.
  • Recommended for people with sensitive skin and eyes.
  • Smudge-proof.
  • A long period of lockdown.

Our Verdict

This product is highly recommended for anyone with sensitive skin and it is also having great value for money. Therefore this eyeliner emerges as the winner of the most value based product.

Things to look for in an Eyeliner – BUYERS’ GUIDE

How to select the perfect eyeliner. What’s the best eyeliner characteristics? All these questions create a lot of confusion in our minds and we are here to help with the same.
Eyeliner is a makeup product that is used to create more depth and definition for the eyes. Lines can be creatively drawn above the lashes, below the lashes, on the water line or the tightline, in accordance with the features of the eye such as shape, size, lashes, eyebrows and the area below the eyes. An extra wing can be added at the end in order to create a wonderful extension. Smokey eyes effect can be created with the help of a smudger and it can create an aura of mystery around the eyes.

However, there are some things that need to be taken care of when it comes to choosing the best eyeliner for yourself.

A starting step would be the budget, before anything else. It depends on the level of brands and their levels of luxury. Eyeliners range from the luxury range to the value based range and even the budget-friendly ones that many prefer.

First of all, one must check whether the product causes you any allergies. This can be done by applying a sample coating on your wrists. If you are allergic to any of the ingredients used in the formulation, it is imperative that you should look for a more friendly choice.

After deciding on the perfect product with no allergens, you must look for the type of formulation you want. Whether you prefer cake eyeliners over liquid eyeliners, you must decide on the type of the eyeliner. If you are always on the go, the liquid or gel-based eyeliner pen is highly recommended. If you have a brush with fine hair, you can very well go for cake eyeliners. Or if you feel that crème eyeliners work for you, they must definitely be used. This choice depends on your usage and preferences.

Once you are done with that criteria, you must look for the shades you want. Black is the most classic colour and there are various shades of black. There are shiny, matte and normal shades. There are also different colours to chose from. These days there are peach eyeliners that come in nude shades which are quite helpful in creating a shiny lustre over the eyes. There are even wild shades like violet which are meant to pop up different eye colours like grey and green.

After the shades been taken care of, you can now compare the characteristics such as the lockdown period, resistances like being waterproof and smudge resistant. Compare different products. Once you feel confident that a particular product has many advantages over the rest, buy it and add it in your makeup kit. Wear those lashes well drawn.